View

Hiring a creative agency in 2027: what to keep, what to brief out

AI made content volume cheap, so the agency work worth paying for is the part a prompt cannot fake, and it starts with a better brief.

Published
Read5 min
Sources6 cited
FromRevolt Marketing
The short answer

How do I hire and brief a creative agency so the work comes back right?

Keep templated content in house and hire outside for judgment and craft: the story, documentary-grade film, the brand system and a website that makes the case. Forrester predicts enterprises will insource up to 60% of templated production. Then brief for one business problem and one audience, not deliverables, because 78% of marketers think their briefs are clear and only 5% of agencies agree.

Keep the repeatable work in house and buy judgment from outside. AI has made templated content cheap enough that most growing companies should now produce their own social variants and resized ads. What an outside studio should do for you in 2027 is the work a prompt cannot fake: finding the true story, and filming real people doing real work. Hire for that, and brief for the business problem instead of a list of deliverables.

AI is splitting agencies into two kinds

Forrester’s newest predictions say the agency business is about to divide. In [Predictions 2027: Marketing Agencies Divide Between Orchestration And Execution]( https://www.forrester.com/blogs/predictions-2027-marketing-agencies-divide-between-orchestration-and-execution/), Forrester principal analyst Jay Pattisall argues that the old agency model, which grew by adding people and billable hours, cannot survive the speed and cost of AI. Agencies will sort into “orchestrators,” which redesign how marketing teams operate and govern their use of AI, and “executors,” which supply specialist work AI cannot authentically deliver.

Clients are moving faster than most agencies admit. [Forrester]( https://www.forrester.com/blogs/predictions-2027-marketing-agencies-divide-between-orchestration-and-execution/) found that 67% of B2C marketing decision-makers call insourcing creative and production a high priority for the next 12 months. It predicts enterprises will bring up to 60% of templated content production in house, meaning blogs, social posts and image or video variants. Earlier this year a [NewtonX survey for Adweek]( https://www.adweek.com/agencies/as-ai-fuels-in-housing-surge-agency-execs-take-the-entrepreneurial-path/) found that 32% of brands expected to handle nearly all of their creative work in house within a year.

This is no longer a big-brand story. [Digiday reported on October 2]( https://digiday.com/marketing/marketings-upper-middle-embraces-ai-creative-production/) that Brandtech’s Pencil platform is growing fastest among companies with under $1 billion in annual revenue. Wyndham Hotels & Resorts told Digiday it now produces 15 times as many assets as before and has cut concepting and production time by 75%.

What to bring in house now

If a piece of content follows a template, your team should own it. That covers resizes and social cuts of an approved campaign, product posts, event recaps and the weekly rhythm of LinkedIn updates. Dollar Shave Club is the extreme case. Laura Higgins, its chief brand and innovation officer, [told Digiday in July]( https://digiday.com/marketing/dollar-shave-clubs-bet-ai-makes-agencies-optional-not-obsolete/) that the company makes 90% of its advertising in house, and that a 4th of July campaign went from idea to launch in about a month using Claude and the AI video tool Higgsfield.

Notice how she frames it. “[AI] isn’t the strategy, it’s an execution device,” Higgins said. The speed comes from having the strategy settled before anyone opens a tool.

Two cautions belong here. Cheap volume carries real risk: in its [2027 predictions for CMOs]( https://www.forrester.com/blogs/predictions-2027-cmos-reckon-with-an-ai-reality-check/), Forrester reports that 64% of US B2C marketing executives believe their AI use is likely to cause a brand-damaging incident within 12 months, and 82% expect to justify future AI spending more strictly. And some work should stay with people by policy. Victor Gonzalez, senior director of creative at BetMGM, [told Digiday]( https://digiday.com/marketing/marketings-upper-middle-embraces-ai-creative-production/), “You can’t hold AI accountable,” which is why the company keeps part of its production with human staff.

What is still worth hiring out

Hire outside for the work where authenticity is the product. When every competitor can generate a polished ad by Friday, the scarce asset is proof: real footage of your people and your work, shaped into a story worth finishing. Dollar Shave Club draws the same line. Higgins said its military campaign would use only real footage, while a product launch would be fully AI-generated.

In practice, four things are worth paying a specialist for:

  • The story. Finding what is true and distinct about your company, and cutting the rest.
  • Documentary-grade film. Interviews and behind-the-work footage that show buyers something no model could invent.
  • The brand system. Identity and voice, plus templates good enough that your in-house volume looks like one company instead of twenty.
  • A website that makes the case. It is the asset every buyer, and every AI assistant, checks before anyone picks up the phone.

Our position is simple. If an agency’s main value is volume, you are paying for something AI already made cheap. If its value is judgment and craft, you are buying the part that just became more valuable.

Why agency work comes back wrong

Most disappointing agency work starts with the brief, and the people who write briefs rarely see it. Global research from the BetterBriefs project, co-authored by Mark Ritson and [reported by Marketing Week]( https://www.marketingweek.com/best-practice-guide-better-briefs/), found that 78% of marketers believed their briefs gave clear direction. Only 5% of agencies agreed. The same project estimated that 26% of UK marketers’ budgets are wasted on poor briefs and misdirected work.

Experience does not fix it. In the BetterBriefs UK survey, 72% of the people writing briefs had more than 10 years of marketing experience, yet only 6% of agencies said they were clear on the strategic direction in client briefs.

AI raises the stakes. When production was expensive, a vague brief wasted one shoot. Now it can produce hundreds of assets pointed the wrong way before anyone notices.

How to brief a creative agency in 2027

A brief for outside work should answer different questions than it did five years ago. Before you send one, check that it covers these:

  1. The business problem, in one sentence. “Win more mid-size healthcare clients in Florida” gives a team something to aim at; “a brand video” does not.
  2. The one person you need to move. Name their role and the belief you need to change.
  3. The truth only you have. Point the agency to the people it can film and the results it can quote. Access is the most underrated line in any brief.
  4. What your team will make from it. Say which assets you will cut down and reuse in house, so the core story and system are built to travel.
  5. How you will judge it. One measure that matters to the business, agreed before work starts.

Then walk the agency through it in person. The document starts the conversation; it does not replace it.

A prediction, labelled as one: by 2028 the agencies that last will be smaller, closer to their clients and paid for thinking rather than hours. Forrester expects the winners to be boutiques and large firms that keep top talent and offer differentiated creative thinking. That favours founder-led studios that make the work in house, the model we chose at Revolt. If you are deciding what to keep and what to hand out next year, start by writing the one-sentence business problem, then bring it to a conversation with us.

✓

Do this now

  1. 01

    List every content type you produce and move anything that follows a template in house this quarter.

  2. 02

    Reserve your agency budget for story, film, brand system and website work that depends on real people and real footage.

  3. 03

    Rewrite your next brief around one business problem and one person you need to persuade.

  4. 04

    Tell the agency which assets your team will reuse, so the core work is built to be cut down.

  5. 05

    Agree on one business measure before work starts, and brief the agency in person.

Questions people ask next

Still wondering?

Usually both, split by type of work. Templated, repeatable content is now cheap enough to produce internally with AI tools. Story, film and brand work still benefit from a specialist who brings craft and an outside view.

One business problem in a sentence, the one person you need to persuade, the people and results the agency can access, the assets your team will reuse, and one measure of success. Anything else is supporting detail.

Look at what you are billed for. If the scope is mostly counts of posts, resizes and variants, that work is now cheap to make in house. If the scope is built around a story, a film or a system your team will use for years, you are paying for judgment.

It can be. Forrester reports that 64% of US B2C marketing executives expect their AI use to cause a brand-damaging incident within 12 months. Set clear rules on what AI may depict, and have a person approve anything public.